EDHECinfra Post
Fake infra threatens real deal
Publication date: 2016-10-06

This post was originally published on the top1000funds website.

Support for infrastructure investment, the idea that asset owners should commit to long-term capital projects through a mix of debt and equity, is a powerful notion  at the heart of several important public and investment policy areas. It has  been much discussed. It has become a staple of high-level G20 and European Union  meetings. It has traveled from obscure trade publications to the mainstream financial  press. It has practically become fashionable.

Infrastructure investment has also long been the preserve of large, sophisticated players,  because it is complex and relatively expensive, but the many smaller pension  plans and insurers increasingly find themselves unable to avoid the question: ‘Why  aren’t we investing in infrastructure yet?’

Especially now. With listed infrastructure, suddenly anyone can invest in ‘infra’. A  liquid, easy-to-understand investment proposition offers to deliver all the benefits of  private infrastructure investment without the hassle of locking up funds with a private  manager or needing your own infrastructure deal team. Even your grandparents  could do it. In fact, they do – or so they’re told.

In a new Ecole des hautes Etudes Commerciales du Nord (EDHEC) position paper,  we document the dangerous rise of the so-called listed infrastructure asset class, an  ill-defined series of financial products that initially targeted retail investors and is increasingly  used by institutional investors, which now represent close to a third of the  market.

Promising to deliver the benefits of the infrastructure investment narrative, listed  infrastructure has been growing by 15 per cent annually for a decade, reaching at  least $57 billion in assets under management (AUM) today.  But a review of published academic research shows that these products fail to deliver  on their many promises. Listed infrastructure, as it is proposed to investors today,  exhibits high drawdowns and volatility, does not have better risk-adjusted performance  than broad market stock indices, and shows behaviour easily explained by a  series of well-known factor tilts available to investors throughout the sharemarket.

The number of false claims made about this asset class is high enough to consider a  mis-selling case, and in open letters to the United States Securities and Exchange  Commission and the European Securities and Markets Authority, we recommend  stricter regulatory oversight of these products, including the obligation to include the  word ‘listed’ in their names to avoid misleading investors, along with the obligation  to include information in marketing documents and information kits warning that  listed infrastructure may not deliver the same performance as unlisted infrastructure  investments.

For the new position paper, EDHEC reviewed the marketing documentation of 144  listed infrastructure products, representing 85 per cent of the sector by AUM, and  concluded that such products typically make claims nearly identical to those of private  infrastructure products.

We also performed new tests, extending existing research, that use the actual constituents  of both passive and active listed infrastructure products, capturing most  available listed investment products using the word ‘infrastructure’ in their name.  We found even less convincing results than in previous studies, which relied on  back-filled indices using data from a period when no listed infrastructure product  even existed.

We found that active listed infrastructure managers have invested in close to 1900  different stocks over the last decade, half of which cannot possibly be considered infrastructure  under any definition. They include brand names such as Amazon, Microsoft  and Nintendo.

A growing shadow 

The growth of listed infrastructure products is problematic because of the damage  that their proliferation will eventually do to proper infrastructure investing.  We believe in the potential of infrastructure debt and equity investment for asset  owners. We also see no reason why, in principle, some of the products used to access  the characteristics of underlying infrastructure assets could not be listed on public  markets.

But today’s fake infra will disappoint. It is comparatively expensive (fees are higher  than for other mutual funds) and will leave investors without the promised low-risk,  stable, inflation-linked returns. As a result, it could give a bad name to infrastructure  investing in general.

Fake infra could reverse years of investor education about the potential of infrastructure  assets as sources of portfolio diversification and liability hedging. It could  also undo recent progress in the prudential area towards recognising the existence of  a specific risk-return profile and capital-charge treatment for infrastructure debt and  equity.

It may even jeopardise the involvement of institutional investors in the next generation  of public-private partnerships that have come to underpin so much of the national  infrastructure plans most Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development  governments have put forward.

Eventually, sharemarket regulators should aim to achieve a clear definition of the listed  infrastructure space, within which, listed infrastructure products that are better  and more transparent could be created, with the aim of delivering at least some of the  promises of infrastructure investment to asset owners.

Such a definition was developed in the context of the prudential regulation of insurers,  pension plans and banks. Sharemarket regulators can use it to define which underlying  assets would qualify to be included in listed equity products, as with other  categories or groupings of stocks.

Furthermore, asset owners should require transparency and that listed infrastructure  asset managers always publish their constituents; they should require valid evidence  of listed products delivering on the narratives of infrastructure investment; and they  should benchmark listed infrastructure products against unlisted ones.

We hope that those asset managers who are truly committed to infrastructure investment  will support our call for clarity in the public-equity space, so that listed vehicles  can be used to create products that genuinely offer new, rewarded risk exposures and  help support the worthy goal of matching long-term capital with the infrastructure  needs of the world.


  • The information contained on the EDHECinfra website (the “information”) has been prepared by EDHECinfra solely for informational purposes, is not a recommendation to participate in any particular investment strategy and should not be considered as an investment advice or an offer to sell or buy certain securities.

    All information provided by EDHECinfra is impersonal and not tailored to the needs of any person, entity or group of persons. The information shall not be used for any unlawful or unauthorised purposes. The information is provided on an “as is” basis.

    Although EDHECinfra shall obtain information from sources which EDHECinfra considers to be reliable, neither EDHECinfra nor its information providers involved in, or related to, compiling, computing or creating the information (collectively, the “EDHECinfra Parties”) guarantees the accuracy and/or the completeness of any of this information.

    None of the EDHECinfra Parties makes any representation or warranty, express or implied, as to the results to be obtained by any person or entity from any use of this information, and the user of this information assumes the entire risk of any use made of this information. None of the EDHECinfra Parties makes any express or implied warranties, and the EDHECinfra Parties hereby expressly disclaim all implied warranties (including, without limitation, any implied warranties of accuracy, completeness, timeliness, sequence, currentness, merchantability, quality or fitness for a particular purpose) with respect to any of this information.

    Without limiting any of the foregoing, in no event shall any of the EDHECinfra Parties have any liability for any direct, indirect, special, punitive, consequential or any other damages (including lost profits), even if notified of the possibility of such damages.

    All EDHECinfra Indices and data are the exclusive property of EDHECinfra. Information containing any historical information, data or analysis should not be taken as an indication or guarantee of any future performance, analysis, forecast or prediction. Past performance does not guarantee future results. In many cases, hypothetical, back-tested results were achieved by means of the retroactive application of a simulation model and, as such, the corresponding results have inherent limitations.

    The Index returns shown do not represent the results of actual trading of investable assets/securities. EDHECinfra maintains the Index and calculates the Index levels and performance shown or discussed, but does not manage actual assets. Index returns do not reflect payment of any sales charges or fees an investor may pay to purchase the securities underlying the Index or investment funds that are intended to track the performance of the Index. The imposition of these fees and charges would cause actual and back-tested performance of the securities/fund to be lower than the Index performance shown. Back-tested performance may not reflect the impact that any material market or economic factors might have had on the advisor’s management of actual client assets.

    The information may be used to create works such as charts and reports. Limited extracts of information and/or data derived from the information may be distributed or redistributed provided this is done infrequently in a non-systematic manner. The information may be used within the framework of investment activities provided that it is not done in connection with the marketing or promotion of any financial instrument or investment product that makes any explicit reference to the trademarks licensed to EDHECinfra (EDHECinfra, Scientific Infra and any other trademarks licensed to EDHEC Group) and that is based on, or seeks to match, the performance of the whole, or any part, of a EDHECinfra index. Such use requires that the Subscriber first enters into a separate license agreement with EDHECinfra. The Information may not be used to verify or correct other data or information from other sources.

    The terms contained in this Disclaimer are in addition to the Terms of Service for users without a subscription applicable to the EDHECinfra website, which are incorporated herein by reference.

    This site uses cookies to deliver the services you request, improve user experience and measure audience. By continuing to browse our website, you are consenting to our use of cookies. Find out more about this in our Privacy policy.

  • X